Plain Vanilla Games
Plain Vanilla Games was the creator of QuizUp, one of the fastest-growing mobile games in history. QuizUp was a social trivia app that gained 20 million users in its first six months. Despite its massive popularity and a high-profile partnership with NBC for a television show, the company collapsed when the TV deal was canceled and the game failed to generate enough revenue to sustain its massive operational costs.
The Autopsy
| Section | Details |
|---|---|
| Startup Profile | Founders: Thor Fridriksson Funding: ~$40M from Sequoia Capital, Greycroft Partners, and Tencent |
| Cause of Death | Financing Failure: The NBC 'Hail Mary': The company banked its entire future on an NBC television game show based on the app. When NBC canceled the show just before production, the company lost its projected revenue and marketing lifeline. Market Fit: The Monetization Gap: Despite having 40 million users, QuizUp struggled to convert players into paying customers. The game was 'too free,' and the social networking features didn't lead to strong ad revenue. Other: High Burn Rate: Maintaining a social network with millions of real-time users required a massive engineering team and server infrastructure that the company could no longer afford. |
| The Critical Mistake | Over-reliance on a Single Partner: Plain Vanilla stopped focusing on internal monetization experiments because they believed the NBC deal would provide the 'exit' or the massive cash infusion needed to reach profitability. |
| Key Lessons |
|
Deep Dive
QuizUp was a masterpiece of design. It allowed users to compete in over 1,000 specific topics (from Breaking Bad to Quantum Physics), creating thousands of micro-communities. The 'Sequoia Effect' The company's rapid rise was fueled by Sequoia Capital. Being the first Icelandic startup to receive such high-tier VC backing put immense pressure on them to be the 'next big thing.' This led to aggressive hiring and expansion in both Reykjavik and San Francisco, creating a 'burn rate' that was unsustainable without a massive revenue event. The End in Iceland On August 31, 2016, the news broke in Iceland that the office was closing and all 36 remaining employees were being laid off. The founder, Thor Fridriksson, expressed that the NBC cancellation was the final blow. As noted in the Iceland Review, the company had 'run out of road.' The Legacy QuizUp didn't stay dead forever. The assets were eventually acquired by Glu Mobile (later EA) for a fraction of the company's peak valuation. Thor Fridriksson went on to found Teatime Games, applying the lessons of QuizUp to a new era of 'real-time' social gaming. Plain Vanilla remains a legendary story in the Nordic tech scene—a reminder of how quickly a 'Unicorn' can fall when the business model doesn't match the hype.
Key Lessons
Don't Bank on Hollywood: Media deals are notoriously fickle. Never let a partnership with a traditional media giant become your only path to survival.
Scale is a Liability Without Revenue: In the world of apps, 40 million users are 40 million 'mouths to feed' (server costs). If they don't pay, they eventually sink the ship.
Focus on the Core: The company spent significant resources turning QuizUp into a social network, which users didn't necessarily want, instead of perfecting the gaming experience.